The Ultimate Guide to Perfect Cheese Toasties: Elevating a Comfort Food Classic

BY: Sharon Fitness for GOOD.

There’s something universally comforting about a cheese toastie, right? It’s no wonder the Hope Valley kids favourite menu item at the Queen of Hearts. Simple, satisfying, and endlessly customisable, it’s the kind of snack that never goes out of style. But while the basic formula of bread, cheese, and heat is hard to beat, there are plenty of ways to take your cheese toastie from good to absolutely irresistible.

Whether you’re after the perfect crunch, luxurious melt, or gourmet flair, here’s how to make cheese toasties truly sing.

The Foundation: Bread Matters More Than You Think

The bread is not just a vessel – it’s half the experience. Here’s how to choose wisely:

  • Sourdough: For a crunchy, chewy bite that holds up well to rich fillings.
  • Brioche: Adds a sweet, buttery note and a soft texture – perfect for a decadent treat.
  • Thick-Cut White Bread: Classic and nostalgic, ideal for a golden, crispy finish.
  • Grainy, Seeded or Rye Bread: For added depth of flavour and a hearty feel.

Pro Tip: Lightly toast your bread before adding cheese if you want to prevent sogginess from moist fillings.

Ooey, gooey, melty, crunchy and oh so satisfying.
The Star Ingredient: Cheese Combinations That Melt Hearts

Good toasties are all about the melt. Great toasties layer flavour too.

Best Melting Cheeses:
  • Cheddar (sharp, flavourful, and easy to find)
  • Tasty Cheese (an Australian staple – rich and bold)
  • Mozzarella (for that gooey, stretchy pull)
  • Gruyère (nutty, slightly sweet – widely available in better delis & supermarkets)
  • Colby (mild, creamy, and melts beautifully)
  • Swiss Cheese (Emmental or Jarlsberg) (sweet, nutty, and perfect for toasting)
The Ultimate Blend:

Mix Tasty cheese for punch, Colby for creamy melt, and a bit of mozzarella for that satisfying stringiness. Add a touch of Gruyère or Swiss cheese for a gourmet edge.

Pro Tip: Always grate your cheese rather than slicing – it melts faster, more evenly, and gives you that perfect gooey texture.

Butter, Mayo, or Both?

The secret to golden perfection isn’t just in the bread or cheese – it’s in the spread:

  • Butter: Classic choice for rich flavour and crispiness.
  • Mayonnaise: Surprisingly good for even browning and a subtle tang.
  • Garlic Butter: Adds savoury depth and elevates every bite.

Pro Tip: Spread your fat of choice right to the edges to avoid dry spots.

Next-Level Fillings: Beyond Just Cheese

While cheese should always be the hero, these extras can turn your toastie into a gourmet delight:

  • Caramelised onions (sweetness and umami)
  • Tomato slices (freshness, but pat dry to avoid sogginess)
  • Prosciutto or ham (salty, savoury bite)
  • Jalapeños (a spicy kick)
  • Pickles or chutney (tang and texture)
  • Fresh herbs (basil, thyme, or chives for aroma and flavour lift)

Pro Tip: Don’t overfill – keep a good cheese-to-filling ratio to ensure meltiness isn’t compromised.

Cooking Methods: Crisp, Crunch & Control
  • Pan-Fried on Medium Heat: Classic and controlled, allowing you to monitor browning.
  • Sandwich Press: Even pressure for a neat, café-style toastie.
  • Cast Iron Pan + Weight: For a homemade “pressed” effect (use a smaller pan or foil-wrapped brick).
  • Oven Finish: Bake at 180°C for 5 mins post-pan-fry to melt cheese through thicker toasties.

Pro Tip: Flip and press gently for even toasting – don’t rush with high heat or you’ll burn the outside before the cheese melts.

Pro-Level Touches to Elevate Your Cheese Toastie
  • Cheese Crust: Sprinkle grated cheese on the outer side of the bread for a crispy, caramelised cheese crust.
  • Truffle Oil Drizzle: A few drops before serving for indulgent aroma.
  • Hot Honey Drizzle: Sweet-spicy contrast that pairs beautifully with salty cheeses.
  • Finishing Salt & Fresh Cracked Pepper: Simple, but heightens flavours.
  • Dipping Sauces: Tomato soup, mustard aioli, or spicy chutneys.
The Final Bite: Cheese Toastie Nirvana

At its heart, the cheese toastie is simple comfort food. But with a little care and creativity, you can turn it into a gourmet experience that satisfies every craving. Whether you’re perfecting the classic or pushing boundaries with flavour twists, the humble cheese toastie will always have a place in our hearts – for sunday lunch, a midnight snack or any time at all!

Watch When Calls the Heart season 12 on Friday nights at 7:30pm AEST on GOOD. or stream from the free GOOD app. Watch now: CLICK HERE.

About the Author: Sharon Fitness is a staff writer for GOOD. She’s a movie buff, TV fan, foodie and dog lover.